Math Small Groups: What’s the Rest of the Class Doing? with Kim Rimbey
Below is adapted from the video.
If you want the full context PLUS all the visuals I shared, watch the video.
Welcome fellow Recovering Traditionalists!!
You finally get your small group to the table and you start working with them… and then a hand goes up. Then another hand goes up. Three kids want to come up and talk to you. Five kids aren’t doing anything, and two are over there messing around.
If that’s what small group time looks like in your classroom every day, this post is for you.
I recently sat down with Kim Rimbey, author of Meaningful Small Groups in Math, to talk about all things small groups. Small groups are a great way to work with kids on a particular concept they need help with, or to extend their thinking. But they can also lead to chaos in the rest of the classroom. So let’s dig into how to keep that from happening.
The Ocean and the Lifeguard Station
Kim uses a metaphor she got from her friend Alisha: the class is the ocean, and the small group area is the lifeguard station.
Why the ocean? It comes from the movie Kindergarten Cop. When Arnold Schwarzenegger’s character goes undercover as a kindergarten teacher, the principal walks him through his responsibilities and tells him that kindergarten is like the ocean. You never want to turn your back on it.
That’s the mindset Kim brings to small groups. When she’s at the lifeguard station with her three, four, or five students, she sits facing the ocean and her group sits facing away from it. She can always see what’s going on out there.
But being able to SEE the ocean isn’t enough. The kids out there need to know what’s expected, what routines are in place, and what’s not okay. One of Kim’s tools is a “parking lot” where kids can write their name when they need her. She sees them write it, gives them a wink, and then supports them when the group wraps up.
Routines first. THEN small groups.
Who Comes to the Lifeguard Station?
We are so data heavy these days. Data is coming at us from every direction, and Kim says all of it serves a purpose. But the data some people often hold in the highest regard (benchmark data collected three times a year, standardized test data, even unit test data) has a shelf life when it comes to grouping kids.
“The further away you are from having collected that data, the less useful it is for putting kids into small groups.” – – Kim Rimbey
For Kim, the most important data is what she collects EVERY day: classwork and observations. She walks around with a clipboard all the time, noting what she sees and who might need some extra support. Her favorite? Exit tickets. She can sort them and quickly figure out who needs what, whether that’s a heterogeneous group or a group that needs to work on one specific skill.
And “extra support” doesn’t only mean intervention. Sometimes the purpose of a small group is to take kids who are really getting it a step further.
Some Math Groups Only Last Ten Minutes
One thing I loved from our full training that Kim did for the members of the Build Math Minds PD site, is that small groups can be spontaneous. You’re circling the room, you notice a need, and you pull those kids right then for some just-in-time support.
Kim pointed out that this is a big difference between math groups and reading foundations groups. Reading groups often stay together for three, four, or five weeks.
“Sometimes my math small groups are together for ten minutes.” – – Kim Rimbey
It’s this kid and this kid and this kid, right now, because they need it in the moment. And we have to be open to the fact that it’s not always who we’d predict. Sometimes someone just didn’t get it, and it’s not the kid you would have expected.
That spontaneity is exactly why the routines matter so much. You can only pull a group on the fly if everybody left in the ocean already knows what to do.
What Should the Rest of the Class Be Doing?
This was THE question in the chat during our full training. Everyone wanted to know what the kids in the ocean should be doing while the teacher is at the lifeguard station.
Kim’s answer: it looks slightly different in every classroom. It could be centers, rotation stations, or a menu of things kids need to complete sometime in the next week. Kids might work in set groups or flexible groups. That’s up to you and your style.
What doesn’t change is the need for a system. When Kim started teaching, her mentor told her, “You have to have a system for everything.” So when she helps teachers set up small groups, the first conversation is: what’s your system for the ocean?
Practice independence BEFORE you pull a single group
Here’s the step that is reeaallyy tempting to skip…Kim doesn’t set up her system one day and start small groups the next. She spends a few days making sure everyone knows what’s expected, including what to do when they need help. (Some teachers use “ask three, then me.” Kim uses her parking lot.)
Then she takes a couple more days to make herself LESS accessible. Kim borrowed Peter Liljedahl’s idea of being “purposefully less helpful.” She removes herself to a spot where kids can’t easily get to her and only steps in as needed. No small group yet, just practice working independently.
This is so key. Kids can’t do something they haven’t had a lot of practice with. If most of their time in your classroom has relied on you, you can’t just say “okay, go for it” and expect independence.
And the activities in the ocean have to be things kids can actually do on their own. If it’s brand new math content, guess where everybody is going to end up? At the lifeguard station wanting you to save them.
Kim’s go-to centers
- Games. Kim almost always has a card and dice game center, at every grade level. These are age-appropriate games the class has already played together, so kids can review concepts or do some problem solving without needing her.
- Geometry and measurement, all year long. Those topics often get pushed to the last few weeks of school, but as Kim put it, “that’s not how geometric thinking develops. It develops based on ongoing experience all year long.” Think tangrams, pattern blocks, the SET game, and simple task cards that build spatial understanding, with measurement tied right in.
- The office. This is where kids do paperwork. But it has fun writing utensils, whiteboards, and markers, so it feels like a place they WANT to go.
- Technology. Usually there’s some kind of tech center. But a lot of teachers in our chat said they’re done with technology in their classroom. Then don’t do a technology station! Put something else there.
Mix up your groups out in the ocean
If Kim is working with the same small groups for a few days, she makes sure those kids are NOT all at the same center together. She’ll pull two kids from this group, one from that group, two from another. That way everyone in the ocean is still working in a heterogeneous group.
Rotations or self-selected stations?
Kim prefers self-selected stations over rotating on a timer. Kids don’t all finish at the same time, even when they’re playing the same card game in pairs. So she lets them move independently, with the responsibility of getting to certain stations during the week and finishing all their work.
She also said that’s HER preference because that’s just what fits her style. She has friends who do a spectacular job with rotations.
There’s No One-Size-Fits-All (But There IS a System)
That’s my biggest takeaway from this conversation. There’s no single right way to do small groups. But there is a sequence that works:
- Get your routines in place.
- Make sure kids understand them.
- Scaffold yourself out of the picture so kids practice working independently.
- THEN run your centers in whatever way works for you, your teaching style, and your students.
Every Child Deserves a VIP Experience
Kim has a t-shirt that says, “Not every child learns in the same way on the same day.” Small groups give kids a chance to learn in their own way, on the day that makes sense for them.
And small groups aren’t just for intervention.
“I want every child to get a chance to be in a small group and feel seen and heard and special. I want every child to have that VIP experience when they come to a small group at least once a week.” – – Kim Rimbey
If you want to go deeper, Kim has an entire book on getting math small groups going: Meaningful Small Groups in Math. You can also watch our full conversation if you are a member of the Build Math Minds PD site. If you aren’t a member go here to join: https://buildmathminds.com/bmm
RESOURCES
Kim’s book Meaningful Small Groups in Math
Join the Build Math Minds PD site to watch the full training Kim did plus the resources we created to help you do small groups in your classroom.
Welcome! I’m a Recovering Traditionalist elementary teacher and now, I help teachers and children learn to love math. Explore how I can help provide you PD at your fingertips! BuildMathMinds.com